Abstract

Today, personal data is a key resource for companies. It helps them understand how individuals think, spend, and behave, enabling businesses to direct their products and services to specific groups based on personal habits and preferences. 

With rapid advancements in technology and artificial intelligence, the right to privacy has become increasingly important in the digital age. Individuals regularly share personal information with businesses, digital platforms, and government authorities, which exposes such data to the risk of misuse. The growing dependence on digital systems has also led to new forms of crime, including data fraud, phishing, and cyberbullying.

To address these concerns, India enacted its first comprehensive data protection law—the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023—on 11 August 2023. While the legislation marks an important step forward, it still falls short of providing a fully robust and comprehensive privacy framework. Much like the Indian Constitution drew inspiration from foreign constitutions, India’s data protection regime can also benefit from examining international models, particularly the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation, 2018 (GDPR).

The European Union has developed a strong and well-structured legal framework to protect the right to privacy. In India, the right to privacy was formally recognised as a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution in the Puttaswamy judgment, reflecting a similar commitment to protecting individual autonomy and dignity.

This paper examines the scope and limitations of privacy laws in India and the European Union. It compares the philosophical and legal foundations of privacy in both jurisdictions and seeks to offer recommendations for strengthening India’s privacy regime through a comparative analysis.



INTRODUCTION

Do you know There a device that knows more about you than knows than you know about yourself. that device is your phone, and it knows your sleep patterns it knows your mental behaviours it knows your spending habits and it even knows your insecurities. you might be wondering how my phone knows about that and how is it even possible. There are certain ways the phone analyses your behaviour while some people find it fascinating, but I find it concerning. Have you ever wondered WhatsApp provide you amazing services but does not charge you anything so how does WhatsApp earns the money from their app. Almost every social media apps that we use are not Indian apps they come under a single company which is Meta owned by Mark Zuckerberg. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 marks a significant development in Indian privacy law, aiming to safeguard the personal data of citizens. However, from a legal standpoint, certain provisions appear ambiguous and open to interpretation. This paper seeks to critically examine the Act by comparing it with international data protection frameworks, assessing its strengths, limitations, and practical implications. The jurisprudence of the DIGITAL PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION ACT, 2023 goes back to a Aadhaar Welfare scheme which was challenged by a retired Indian judge K.S Puttaswamy and this petition led to the recognition of right to privacy as a fundamental right.      

The Right to privacy is one of the fundamental rights under the Indian constitution and its importance can be validated by seeing that it is under the article 21 Right to life which signifies its importance and demands for a fully robust and comprehensive privacy legal framework. The recognition of right to privacy is highlighted under the Puttaswamy judgment where the Supreme Court of India recognized the right to privacy as a fundamental right under the Indian constitution and after several years the legislation passed the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 on 11 August 2023.

Unlike the Digital Personal Data Protection Act the European Union did not need a precedent to draft The General Data Protection Regulation,2018. The General Data Protection Regulation April 2016 and It came into full force on 25 May 2018. The General Data Protection Regulation is considered one of the strictest data privacy laws as per the international Standards. The European Union recognizes privacy as a basic human right and Articles 7 and 8 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, which recognize: Respect for private life (Article 7) Protection of personal data (Article 8)


OBJECTIVES OF THIS STUDY:

  • To examines the scope and limitations of privacy laws in India.

  • Comparative Study of the philosophical and legal foundations of privacy in both Jurisdictions.

  • Examine the best practices of Eu privacy law that India can adopt. 


  1. Overview of the DIGITAL PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION ACT, 2023 

Before 2017, India lacked a comprehensive data privacy law. The Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000, and its amendments provided some safeguards, but these were fragmented and inadequate. Sensitive data, especially in healthcare, was often mishandled, leading to breaches and loss of public trust.

For instance, the Aadhaar data breach in 2018 exposed the personal information of millions, highlighting the vulnerabilities in India’s data protection mechanisms. Healthcare organizations, which handle extremely sensitive patient data, were particularly at risk. Without clear guidelines, hospitals, clinics, and digital health platforms struggled to protect patient confidentiality, leading to instances of data misuse and unauthorized access.

CASE LAW: Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India  

1. Background of the Case

The writ petition was filed under Article 32 of the Constitution by Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.), challenging the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar scheme on the ground that it infringed the right to privacy.

At that time, the Union Government argued that the Constitution of India did not expressly recognize a fundamental right to privacy. The Government relied on two earlier precedents:

  • M.P. Sharma v. Satish Chandra (1954)

  • Kharak Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1962)

Both had indicated that privacy was not a constitutionally guaranteed fundamental right. Because of this conflict in precedent, the matter was referred to a nine-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court.

2. The Judgment by the Court 

The nine-judge Bench unanimously held that:

The right to privacy is a constitutionally protected fundamental right under Article 21 and is an intrinsic part of the right to life and personal liberty.

The Court expressly overruled M.P. Sharma and the relevant portions of Kharak Singh.

3. Legal Reasoning Adopted by the Court

The Court did not invent privacy. It derived it through constitutional interpretation using multiple sources the Court held that privacy flows from:

  • Article 21 (Right to Life and Personal Liberty)

  • Article 19 (Freedoms such as speech, movement, association)

  • Article 14 (Equality before law)

It clarified that “life” under Article 21 is not mere animal existence but includes dignity, autonomy, and personal liberty.

One of the Largest Reported Data Breaches in the World

On 10th September 2023 a massive data breach has exposed the personal information of over 815 million Indian residents. A hacker using the alias “pwn0001” claimed on a cybercrime forum that they had access to Aadhaar and passport data, including names, phone numbers, addresses, and identification numbers. The attacker alleged that the data was extracted from records submitted to the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) during COVID-19 testing, though ICMR has not officially confirmed any breach.

To prove the claim, the hacker shared sample spreadsheets containing more than 100,000 Aadhaar records, and cybersecurity firm Security verified that the Aadhaar numbers were authentic. The hacker offered to sell the passport data for $80,000.

Effect of the Data Breach of  2023:-

It is not a coincidence that the very next year the rate of cybercrime saw a astonishing increase of 206% and Indian resident lost over Rs 22845/- crore to cyber fraud and the number of complaints   received by authorities related to cybercrimes was over 36 lakhs complaints. 

The seriousness of this incident can be understood by the fact that the authorities received 410 reports every hour and indians lost roughly 62 crore every day.


B.  Scope of the DIGITAL PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION ACT, 2023

 1. Objective and Legislative Intent

The Act seeks to regulate the processing of digital personal data in a way that balances:

  1. The individual’s right to protect personal data, and

  2. The need to process such data for lawful purposes. 

It is a consent-centric, compliance-driven framework designed specifically for digital ecosystems.

2. Scope and Applicability

The Act applies to:

  • Processing of digital personal data within India, whether collected digitally or collected offline and later digitised.

  • Processing outside India, if connected with offering goods or services to individuals in India 

It does not apply to:

  • Personal or domestic use by individuals.

  • Data made publicly available by the individual or under legal obligation.

3. Key Definitions

The Act introduces core roles:

  • Data Principal: The individual to whom personal data relates.

  • Data Fiduciary: The entity that determines purpose and means of processing.

  • Data Processor: Processes data on behalf of the Fiduciary.

  • Significant Data Fiduciary: A Fiduciary notified by the Central Government based on risk factors.

  • Personal Data: Any data about an identifiable individual.

4. Rights of Data Principals

Data Principals have the right to:

  • Access summary of personal data and processing activities 

  • Know with whom data is shared (subject to law enforcement exceptions) 

  • Correction, completion, updating, and erasure. 

5. Penalties

Penalties are monetary and substantial.

  • Failure to implement reasonable safeguards: up to ₹250 crore.

  • Failure to notify breach: up to ₹200 crore.

  • Breach relating to children: up to ₹200 crore.

  • Significant Data Fiduciary violations: up to ₹150 crore

  • General violations: up to ₹50 crore

  • Frivolous complaints: up to ₹10,000


  1. Limitations of the DIGITAL PERSONAL DATA PROTECTION ACT, 2023

1. No “Sensitive Personal Data” Category

Unlike GDPR, DPDP does not separately define:

  • Health data

  • Biometric data

  • Financial data

All are treated as “personal data” 

2. Broad State Exemption Power

The Central Government can exempt agencies for:

  • Sovereignty

  • Security of the State

  • Public order 

This is constitutionally sensitive.

Proportionality will be tested here.

3. Executive-Controlled Enforcement Body

The Data Protection Board is constituted by the Central Government.

No constitutional insulation like an EU-style independent supervisory authority.

Independence concerns exist.

  1. Research and Methodology 

The respondents were randomly drawn from diverse age groups, genders, and professional backgrounds. The questionnaire consisted of approximately five questions designed to assess individuals’ awareness of the right to privacy and data protection laws in India. The survey further examined perceptions regarding how the sharing of personal data through online platforms affects individuals, along with suggested measures to mitigate its impact.


Key Findings:

A. Level of Concern Regarding Online Privacy

An overwhelming majority reported being highly concerned about online privacy, with only a small minority expressing moderate concern. No participant indicated low or no concern, reflecting a strong perception of privacy risk.

B. Frequently Used Online Services

Instagram was used by nearly all participants, often alongside platforms such as Amazon. Facebook usage was comparatively limited and appeared only in combination with other services. This indicates high engagement with social media and e-commerce platforms.


C. Measures Taken to Protect Online Privacy

A clear majority reported using two-factor authentication (2FA). A smaller segment avoids sharing personal data online, while very few emphasised strong and unique passwords. This suggests some awareness of cybersecurity practices, though security behaviour appears limited rather than comprehensive.

D. Trust in Technology Companies

A substantial majority expressed very little or no trust in major technology companies, while only a minority reported moderate trust. The findings indicate significant scepticism toward corporate data practices.

E. Awareness of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023

Awareness of the DPDP Act was divided, with a slight majority indicating familiarity and a comparable proportion unaware of it. Despite strong privacy concerns, knowledge of the governing legal framework remains inconsistent.


  1. Analysis of the philosophical and legal foundations of privacy in both jurisdictions

Comparative Study: DPDP vs GDPR

Aspect

GDPR

DPDP Act

Legal Foundation

Explicitly rooted in fundamental right to data protection (Recital 1; Article 16 TFEU)

Statutory balancing law recognising privacy + lawful processing

Nature of Right

Independent fundamental right

Statutory right structured by Parliament

Regulatory Authority

Independent supervisory authorities

Data Protection Board appointed by Central Government

State Exemptions

Narrow; must meet strict proportionality

Broad executive exemption powers (Section 7 & 17)

Lawful Bases for Processing

Six structured lawful bases

Consent + legitimate uses

Legitimate Interest Test

Defined with balancing doctrine

Broader and less granular

Data Subject Rights

Access, rectification, erasure, portability, objection, restriction, automated decision safeguards

Access, correction, erasure, grievance redressal

Automated Decision-Making

Article 22 restricts decisions solely based on automation

No detailed equivalent restriction

Children’s Data

Enhanced protection; age flexibility

Strict protection under 18

Cross-Border Data Transfers

Structured adequacy model

Government blacklist model

Penalty Structure

global turnover (up to 4%)

Fixed cap (₹250 crore)


Core Philosophical Difference

Dimension

GDPR

DPDP

Starting Assumption

Data protection is a constitutional shield

Data protection is a regulatory balance

View of State Power

Suspicious; constrained

Trust-based; executive flexibility

View of Business

Must justify processing rigorously

Permitted if lawful purpose exists



  1. Best Practices from EU Privacy Law that India Can Consider Adopting

If DPDP Wants Global Adequacy (Especially EU Adequacy Status)

1. Stronger Regulatory Independence
The Data Protection Board must be institutionally and financially independent from executive control to ensure impartial enforcement.

2. Narrower State Exemptions
Government exemptions should be clearly defined, limited, and subject to necessity and proportionality standards to avoid overbroad surveillance powers.

3. Explicit Proportionality Tests
The law should expressly require that any restriction on privacy be necessary and proportionate to a legitimate objective.

4. Data Portability Right
Users should be able to obtain and transfer their personal data in a structured, machine-readable format to enhance autonomy and competition.

5. Turnover-Based Penalty Scaling
Penalties should be linked to global annual turnover to ensure meaningful deterrence for large corporations.


CONCLUSION:

In the digital era, the right to privacy, though fundamental, is not absolute and must function within a framework that balances individual autonomy with legitimate state and commercial interests.

The comparative study shows that while India’s DPDP Act represents a significant legislative advancement, the EU’s GDPR remains more structurally entrenched and rights oriented. Strengthening regulatory independence, curbing executive discretion, and embedding proportional safeguards would improve both constitutional coherence and India’s global credibility.

REFERENCES: 



About Author :

Mr. AHMED KHAN, T.Y.LL.B

https://www.linkedin.com/in/khan-ahmed-ab588534b?utm_source=share_via&utm_content=profile&utm_medium=member_android